Jamie Carragher has labelled Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes 'a disgrace' for his comments after Manchester United's 4-1 defeat to Como in the Champions League
The former Liverpool defender criticised Fernandes, saying, 'In terms of attitude and the way he goes about things, it's not right at all'
Fernandes appeared to question manager Michael Carrick's tactics, by saying 'you have to be more brave' and urging the 'manager and the staff' to 'take the risk'
Asked about his future, Carrick said he 'had to apologise to the supporters' and that he's 'really angry' about the situation
The defeat leaves Man Utd with just one win in their last nine matches - they're at home to Bournemouth in the Premier Leauge on Sunday
Send your views and have your say in our poll - was Fernandes right to speak out? Paddy says he'd rather have 'academy players who care' | Sam says it shows the deeper problem at Man Utd
Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say
Bruno being captain and the mantra that Manchester United deserve success just because they have had it before are probably two easy things to change. A good footballer does not equate to a good leader and success is earned in the now, not through past glories. It's gone, move forward.
Bob, Cumbria
Como 4-1 Manchester United
Kasper Schmeichel
Former Celtic goalkeeper on the Football Daily podcast
It's a really precarious situation Man United find themselves in now.
I've been in situations myself, as a player you feel like the management and the club aren't aligned from top to bottom and you feel alone out there. I think that's what Bruno Fernandez is doing, he's reacting to feeling alone out there.
He was trying to press but there wasn't anyone following him up and his body language wasn't great. But given what's happened he shouldn't be saying these things, it's not going to help.
You learn that these things are better kept in-house.
Click 'Get Involved' to have your say
You may have spotted that a poll has appeared at the top of this page asking whether you think Bruno Fernandes was right to question Michael Carrick's tactics - if not, give your page a quick refresh.
Anyway, get your votes in and then hit 'get involved' to send us your reasoning.
Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say
Carrick may not be the one to take us forward. But at least he cares for the club and its fans, and you can see he is hurting. Compare that to the players and owners who show little to no care. Let's not forget how well Como played. Throughly deserved win.
Ryan, North Wales
Como 4-1 Manchester United
Joe Cole
Former Chelsea and England midfielder on TNT Sports
Bruno Fernandes is absolutely questioning the tactics and it doesn't matter if he's right to do so. You cannot do that - that's sacrilege.
I've played for managers I've played for where you don't agree with the tactics and you might say that to your mate or your wife. You don't come out, as captain of the club, and question the manager.
He doesn't even do it properly. If you're going to do it, come out and and say it with your chest. He's saying it and he probably thinks he's being clever - 'well I didn't really say it, gaffer'.
You can think the manager has got the tactics wrong, that's fine. Go into his office tomorrow morning and have a conversation but to come out in front of the nation as club captain and question your manager is simply unacceptable.
Hmm. I'd say that an extremely generous interpretation, Christine.
He also said "it's a decision by the staff not to press man-to-man" and how they helped Como find space and gain confidence.
That led to him being directly asked if the tactics were wrong and the quote you mentioned. Personally, I don't think there can be too much doubt he was criticising the manager's tactics...
Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say
Bruno said and I quote, "That's on the manager and staff to say, it's not on me to say". He didn't say that's on the manager and staff. You can read into that however you like but those were his words.
Christine Von Dinther, Nantwich
Como 4-1 Manchester United
Some scathing comments there from Samuel, Ben and Pete. And there are plenty more where they came from!
If you are just joining us, we are just picking through the wreckage of Manchester United's 4-1 Champions League defeat at Como, and the subsequent fallout:
Como 4-1 Manchester United
Simon Stone
BBC Sport Manchester United reporter in Como
Michael Carrick very much reminded me of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer in the way he went to Manchester United’s fans immediately after the 4-1 defeat at Como, and held his hands up in apology.
Solskjaer did something similar after the 4-1 loss to Watford in November 2021.
It is amazing how both situations unravelled so quickly. For Solskjaer, there were 11 games between a home EFL Cup defeat by West Ham and the Watford game, which proved to be his last in charge.
United played their 11th game of the season last night, a campaign that began with that terrible performance at Hull City.
There is no doubting the ‘United’ credentials of both men. But in an environment as unforgiving as this, you have to win matches.
Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say
The problem is entirely of our own making and keeps coming back to the same things: poor decisions by the board and players not being good enough. Until we start making better decisions at the top things won’t get better. I’d rather risk relegation with youth and a proper plan.
Samuel, Skipton
Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say
Bruno has put the owners in a very tough position here. If they sack Carrick, it pretty much shows players have more influence than the managers at Utd. If Carrick stays, he is going to have a massively fractured dressing room.
Ben, Sheffield
Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say
Culmination last night of a lot of things going wrong, it feels to me the wheels are really coming off now. I feel for Carrick, at the very least you want 90 mins of commitment and effort from the players even if we're not good enough to win.
Pete, Welshpool
Como 4-1 Manchester United
Dimitar Berbatov
Former Tottenham and Manchester United striker on TNT Sports
After a performance like this, people will probably raise the same questions like every time.
Are these the players that can compete for United at the highest stage? Is that the right manager? Are we going in the right way?
Of course, after games like this, everybody will say no. We need more players, we need better players, we need this and that.
What can you say after a performance like this? When a loss comes like today, it becomes even more difficult to find the argument that everybody was giving their best because, today, I don't think everyone was giving their best.
It didn't look like that on the pitch. Como were just having fun. It was like watching men against kids.
Image source, Getty ImagesComo 4-1 Manchester United
Simon Stone
BBC Sport Manchester United reporter in Como
All eyes on Manchester United this morning.
Michael Carrick and his players flew back to the North West immediately after their 4-1 Champions League humiliation by Como.
I can’t imagine the atmosphere was convivial given the performance and skipper Bruno Fernandes’ post-match comments about Carrick’s tactics.
Carrick is scheduled to hold a news conference tomorrow to look ahead to Sunday’s Premier League game against Bournemouth.
The key question is whether he will still be in a job after one of the worst performances in United’s entire European history extended the run of games without a win to seven, the worst since they went eight without a win in 2015-16 under Louis van Gaal.
Darren Fletcher stood in as interim boss for two games following Ruben Amorim’s dismissal in January, assisted by Jonny Evans and Travis Binnion, who are both part of Carrick’s current backroom set up.
Carrick could continue, of course, but after controversial post-match outbursts from Lisandro Martinez and Bruno Fernandes in the past week, it doesn’t feel he is presiding over a happy group of players.
Image source, Getty ImagesClick 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say
Whilst on their own Martinez or Fernandes' comments could be excused (though not great in either case) when looked at together, a week apart, they speak to a culture at Man Utd where accountability is dodged and blame shifted. Seems like a rotten institution to me.
Sam, Cambridge
Como 4-1 Manchester United
Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher, speaking as a pundit on broadcaster CBS Sports, described the post-match comments of Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes as "a disgrace":
"We said Lisandro Martinez was bang out of order last week for calling out the hierarchy above him and for Bruno Fernandes to do that is a disgrace really.
"Last season he got 'player of the year'. That was on the back of Michael Carrick becoming manager.
"He wouldn't have got that reward without Michael Carrick because Carrick put him back in his rightful position and he then went on to have a fantastic season because he's a talented footballer.
"In terms of attitude and the way he goes about things, it's not right at all. He's reacted like that because he's been been brought off. He's embarrassed by the manager and he's brought him off."
Image source, Getty ImagesComo 4-1 Manchester United
'How bad was it?' is a question that was being pondered by fans and football pundits alike on Wednesday night as Manchester United head coach Michael Carrick and captain Bruno Fernandes were launching into their own post-match debrief in a very public manner...
Como 4-1 Manchester United
Image source, Getty ImagesWell, it certainly wasn't pretty as far as Manchester United were concerned.
Cesc Fabregas' Como side cut through them time and again with the visitors often left chasing shadows.
In fact, Como's 594 completed passes were the most against United in the Champions League since Barcelona in April 2019 (725).
It led to a situation where, after Jacobo Ramon's header for the Italians, United found themselves four goals down in a Champions League match for the first time since November 1994, when they were beaten 4-0 by Barcelona.
Only Joshua Zirkzee's injury-time consolation prevented United suffering their joint second-worst European defeat of all time.
It was an entirely fair scoreline as well with Como creating four Opta-defined 'big chances' to United's one and comfortably winning the xG, too.
The embarrassment was heightened by the knowledge that when United were last crowned European champions in 2008, Como were playing semi-professional football in front of a couple of hundred spectators in Serie D.
Click 'Get Involved' to have your say
Man Utd players are overpaid and under worked. They feel they are untouchable. I’d rather finish 15th with academy players who care than sack Carrick and get Europe only for the next manager to be sacked when they stop trying. Time to drop the stroppy players.
Paddy, Dublin
Click 'Get Involved' to have your say
Man Utd is like a house with black mould. It doesn't matter how many surface level changes you make, the root of the problem is still there. The whole thing needs ripping out and replacing. Executives, players and manager.
Richard, South Wales
